EFTA00944056

From: Office of Tetje Rod-Larsen < 
Subject: IPI Middle East Update - October 2, 2012 
Date: Tue, 02 Oct 2012 14:38:05 +0000 
INTERNATIONAL PEACE INSTITUTE 
IPI Middle East Update 
October 2, 2012 
Egypt: Egypt's bilateral relations with the United States remain in the headlines as President Morsi traveled to New York 
for the United Nations General Assembly during the week of September 24th. Americans were introduced to President 
Morsi's views on bilateral relations in a lengthy interview published September 23rd in the New York Times. Three points 
of note — Morsi asserted Egypt's independence from the West (not hostile, but less compliant than Mubarak), called on 
the US to fulfill its commitments to the Palestinians under the Camp David Accords to have Israel withdraw from the West 
Bank, and, while noting shared objectives with the United States, pointed out that these objectives are framed by very 
distinct customs and values in the two countries. 
As protests against the anti-Islamic online video trailer produced in the United States have subsided in Egypt, analysts 
looked for a deeper understanding of what fueled the demonstrations. One factor contributing to them is the popular 
Egyptian campaign for the release of Omar Abdel Rahman (known as the Blind Sheikh), who is serving a life sentence in 
the United States for his role in the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center in New York City. There are regular 
demonstrations, sometimes described as sit-ins, of the Blind Sheikh's supporters outside the US Embassy in Cairo. In 
addition, perhaps in a nod to populism, President Morsi publicly stated in June that he will pursue the release of the 
Sheikh. 
The militant activity in the Sinai Peninsula, despite the current Egyptian military campaign against it, continues to raise 
concerns. On Friday, September 21g, militants from a previously unheard of group, "Supporters of the Holy Places," fired 
across the border, killed one Israeli soldier, and wounded another. Security forces, in response, killed the three attackers. 
The incident puts further pressure on the government to rein in the militants and to adeptly manage sensitive security 
relations with Israel. Given that the Camp David Accords limit Egyptian military activity in the Sinai, the Israelis are warily 
watching the Morsi government's actions. In seemingly good news for Egypt and Israel on security issues, President Morsi 
appointed Mohamed Raafat Shehata to serve as the new intelligence chief. Mr. Shehata played a pivotal role in the 
mediation that led to the release of the Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit from Hamas. Thus, he is a known quantity to his Israeli 
counterparts and his appointment would appear to bode well for a level of trust in the lines of communication on the 
most sensitive security issues. 
Libya: The death of Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans during violent attacks against American facilities 
in Benghazi on September 11th has generated strong responses from the Libyan people and government. On Friday, 
September 21g, in actions reminiscent of the 2011 Arab Spring, thousands of Libyans took to the streets in Benghazi and 
overwhelmed the camp of the militant Islamic group, Ansar al-Sharia (Supporters of Islamic Law), perceived to be the 
perpetrators of the crime. The protesters later took over a camp of another militia group and invited the police to assume 
responsibilities for the two sites. Two militias in the city Darna voluntarily dissolved themselves. The Libyan government 
subsequently demanded militias not cooperating with the Ministry of Defense to dismantle their camps and surrender to 
the state. 
Two dynamics are worth highlighting here. First, Libya is witnessing a multiplicity of political forces (old regime diehards, 
new liberals, Islamic fundamentalists, Islamic extremists, groups of ethnic or regional affiliation) competing for power 
politically. Secondly, the recent series of events — circulation of the online anti-Islamic video, violent street protests, the 
West's consistent defense of free speech, and the subsequent publishing of caricatures of the Prophet Mohamed in a 
French newspaper — reinforces the cultural divide between the Islamic world and the West. The Islamic world perceives 
EFTA00944056

the West as having nothing but contempt for Islam and cannot understand the West's commitment to free speech when it 
attacks the divine. The West is perceived as irrationally inflexible on this issue. In turn, the West sees the Islamic world as 
intolerant and violent. This divide serves to reinforce the extremes on both sides of the issue. Salaflsts (the Islamic 
fundamentalists), in particular, are major beneficiaries. 
Tunisia: Protests in Tunis directed at the US Embassy and American school over the anti-Islamic online video resulted in 
the deaths of two Tunisians on September 14th. In response, the Tunisian Ministry of Interior banned demonstrations on 
Friday, September 21g, out of fear of further extremist violence. The government's concern had increased following a 
French newspaper's publication of caricatures of the Prophet Mohamed. After being suppressed for years by the Ben Ali 
regime, Salafists are challenging the state and appear intent on reversing the rights secured by Tunisian women. The 
Salafists' relations with the ruling Islamist party Ennanda are a roller coaster ride circling between cooperation and 
animosity. Some Salafists reject party politics and are working under the banner of Ansar al-Sharia (Supporters of Islamic 
Law — same name but distinct from the Libyan group). The Tunisian group is not calling for jihad at this time, but sees the 
country as ripe for proselytizing. Having rejected party politics and opposed the recent Tunisian elections, the group 
regards the elected assembly as an infidel organ. To them, legislating is solely the provenance of the almighty. In a 
recently released press statement, the leader of Ennanda, described the Salafists as a threat to society and said he 
expected the government and security forces to protect public order. Highlighting widespread concern in Tunisia regarding 
the emergence and activities of the Salafists, former Prime Minister Beji Caid Essebsi (in office from February 2011 to 
December 2011) denounced government policy as permissive and accused the ruling coalition of failing the country and 
allowing the democratic process to stagnate. 
Palestinians: At the United Nations General Assembly the Palestinians requested non-member state status, a step back 
after last year's failure to gain acceptance as a state by the Security Council. 2012 has not been a good year politically or 
economically for the Palestinians. Economic conditions are deteriorating, Israeli settlement expansion continues, the 
peace negotiations have been on pause, and Palestinian Authority reconciliation with rival Hamas seems to be a distant 
possibility. The evolutions of the Arab uprisings and the Iranian nuclear program have the attention of the international 
community rather than the Palestinian cause. There is increasingly more talk in some quarters of abandoning the peace 
process and dissolving the Palestinian Authority. According to press reports, President Abbas told the Palestine Liberation 
Organization leadership that on his return from the United Nations General Assembly ministerial (the week of September 
20), he wants a decision either to abrogate the Oslo Accords or hold a national election to replace him. Experts see this 
more as posturing than a serious position. Abbas has made similar pronouncements in the past. 
Syria: The London-based Syrian Observatory on Human Rights claim that August was the bloodiest month since the start 
of the uprising. The watch group estimated one-fifth of the 25,000 killed since March 2011 died in August. The large death 
toll appears to have resulted from the opposition's reach into densely populated neighborhoods in Damascus, which drew 
an indiscriminate counterattack by the Bashar Al Assad government. In addition, the Syrian conflict continues to spill over 
into neighboring countries. When the opposition forces evicted the Syrian army from a border post aiming to secure their 
supply lines from Turkey, the intensity of the fighting forced Turkish schools in the area to close. Turkey's already restive 
Kurds are also taking advantage of situation. Inspired by Kurdish advances in northeastern Syria, Kurdish fighters have 
been re-energized in their push for autonomy, and Turkey has responded and sent its air force in hot pursuit of the Kurds 
into Iraq. Simultaneously, the conflict in Syria is sharpening the sectarian divide in Iraq and pushing the Baghdad 
government further into the embrace of Iran. 
There are multiple, and seemingly competing, new diplomatic initiatives on Syria. Strong Russian pressure on the Al Assad 
government made it possible for the Syrian domestic opposition to meet in Damascus. While Syria's external opposition 
alleged it was a public relations move orchestrated by Al Assad, the meeting's final communiqué, released in the presence 
of the Russian and Chinese ambassadors, called on President Assad to transfer power peacefully. It also supported a 
ceasefire and withdrawal of the regular army from towns and cities. The United Nations and Arab League Joint Envoy to 
Syria, Lakhdar Brahimi, reported to the Security Council on September 24th. He remains reticent regarding the possibility 
of a peaceful solution and is conducting further international consultations before proposing a new diplomatic approach. 
Egypt is also pursuing its Islamic quartet initiative (Egypt, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Turkey) and hosted a meeting in Cairo on 
Syria. The Syrian National Council's Abdulbasat Sida declared his group opposed to the inclusion of Iran. The Saudi foreign 
EFTA00944057

minister did not attend the Cairo meeting; while this was ostensibly for medical reasons, it would appear that the Saudis 
have serious reservations about Tehran's participation in the process. 
Iraq: Press reports claim Western intelligence has concluded that the Iranian supply operation to the beleaguered Syrian 
regime is bigger and more systematic than first thought. Tens of tons of arms and military personnel are reportedly being 
transported on civilian aircraft daily. The United States and other Western governments are putting pressure on the Iraqi 
government to abide by its obligations and respect the UN embargo on arms exports from Iran and North Korea. Under 
pressure, Iraq denied permission for a North Korean plane bound for Syria to use its air space. In addition over the 
September 22-23rd weekend, an Iraqi government spokesman said authorities would introduce the practice of random 
searches of Syrian-bound Iranian planes. Senator John Kerry, chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, warned that 
US aid to Iraq might be contingent on cutting off flights carrying arms from Iran to Syria. 
Yemen: Saba News Agency reported that that Yemeni President Abed Rabbu Mansour Hadi with cabinet approval has 
formed a committee to investigate human rights crimes committed during the 2011 uprising in the country. The 
committee's mandate may include the ability to indict former president Ali Abdullah Saleh for alleged crimes, even though 
under the Gulf Cooperation Council Initiative he was given immunity for handing over power. 
In other developments in September, the United States refused to grant former president Saleh a visa to visit the US for 
medical reasons without any explanation for the decision. Yemeni political parties and senior officials in the new 
government are very concerned that former President Saleh is working to undermine the transition in the country. A 
major concern is that Saleh's son continues to control the Republican Guards, perhaps the most potent military unit in the 
country. Ambassador Peter Wittig of Germany, serving as the Security Council President this month, noted that the 
Council is concerned about ongoing attempts to undermine the transition process. In addition a high level meeting of the 
Friends of Yemen was held in New York City on September 27 to reaffirm the international community's support for the 
ongoing transition. 
For more information please contact: 
Maureen Quinn at 
or 
Of 
Camilla Reksten-Monsen at 
or 
•The International Peace Institute  (IPI) is an independent, not-for-profit think tank with a staff representing more than 20 nationalities with offices in New York 
across from the United Nations and in Vienna. IPI  promotes the  prevention and settlement of conflicts between and within states by strengthening international 
peace and security institutions. To achieve this  purpose IPI employs a mix of  policy research, convening,  publishing and outreach. The views expressed here do 
not necessarily represent those of IPI. 
EFTA00944058