EFTA00723522

Ode Isetele PSY We% MeaMN. ateweepseistmeeeptsesee 
Rak nami 
PalmBeachPosicom i Archives 
•••••••OWIti.04 
 
Jots 
Aulos 
R04, Ilelobs 
aw cis& 
Puwp4b• 
aha kasa 
sio 
Krn. 
thy 
Weetrc: 
Tr.or.• 
Drs.*,  
Wew(' 
Esegatilinc= 
ftetw. 
Votb.• 
6007 
W•wl CaSelt 
&fksie Isis a Nroyaush
POLICE SAY LAWYER TRIED TO DISCREDIT TEENAGE GIRLS 
WHAM LARRY KILLER. Palm Stach Pat Stać Yen: 
DAT": J.4 ap. 2000 
PUBLICATION: Pam Beach Post. The (EL) 
WTOK fNAt 
Stalak LOCAL 
PAM k 
MIMO: at dl amen 
Filmed „nid I.. wolesG0c Alan DestmeN2 met see Vs Pam Babrz Corey Sum MIGOWO Oko ad patowi alka 
lasowa obar leers;. guts who say they owe Ns dat Pak Boa barowa Je*ey thaw. sartaly ciwrpecl swassapas, 
obawa w pola ropa. 
lb. ara alto ate bol oak Easters atonia/ mrowi to • pea bran eat void low alba Epstein torn no cara 
warz had arat atomy dola ta isaak. NW the docatents also real that the bardonowi one Pd compared 
ea taka ankkalces aparesstddi trarsal Ns cr. reaktrzalled his lame and abs or tisiwy 
arce oho terzed to scrokCCy Ww sad rte was doted money K she rased to wara ta the Pks Beach Pace 
Dad rnel wata of Cahn 
TYra stok Moan tace said k sawa the Eaten. adr hol nudy asa jury his reak raba an dray chata 
twa beam Pacom OWA wo Pni credeonty. lm ona itry taca Epelan. M. on • ago osadka .oskam 
ce prosaka kich aches a madam yenay d he years h Tria 
Piu bawd here at  path cewa to char Ewa WINI* MPO WWI cam d asa ea acts irk a aver sad 
ad end Meath= watka Poke Oat Maar Rea was so ai 
MC ho wole SUN Mln( Sadrz Kleista memos 
May haman° he karzy Wwal acha Ow caw 
Mn cam spindly was Goa to be owad to Be gard lm h Feacry, bA was poshati ate Ocrshar prodarod 
Internalen peered ram the Web she mapa cere ohootsv sane c! sad ene(sX1 Jaime ovemening m almand are Ileeklane 
ocCang to the baca art Paborzd by Oecicbm atat Recede/. 
According to Ramy, paca Lae achatt dka Epan otanks llersaaas Gw Fiona a oho da In Ark. 
Frowan, ker sakwa att Epstei4 kapsl he tantach Epilell woal plead hary to ar cowl of kateted nawa 
with :MOM tama afany. be pad al he yeirS' patiom end haw no carat ma 
Tae Oce sto ala to•Epslch to 
aka to a psychiatric ara sat atak 
and hiw no tasscanlaad gilts MIlt haras. karta ID Recasts repot The ha. 
bash 
mode In ansa"wBh my ada 
Ow Mego] sarna the Wat states. 
Prany,, • who aka 
to camera on Uw omy • to. easequenhy Fed asa wian draw away ka Gola botem n. 
Nred. Noakes kere a 
fl  arroanall 
MW ct Ekleres kanop babrze da. 
'Wc ebsdatty 64 a ace rzepa n VW sae.' he said. 1C&ct Bata+ washer allorzat spokesman chef be 
acta te COffelell. 
7116 wet v patens c t aged Ucha Kk Caktabal d ang Massed By poet trakatar ara 
Were 1ss Wroto,* 
d No of the as Pora kard the trias worz nastawi kapka eye in Wat Pa Beach end pawia haler. 
ammana to Rama repom 
'r hews no knoMathe d n,' Cake dank Orkaate mm. 
The nwol 820 Mrze a wam comasiod to ho eaten case ma cotaCIOC by somebody who twe ela n torah wab Ekler. 
kat pawn rac her ate woja be cmhatawahrd amp dal coopreate Wth posok Ratowys nowt says. hose who did la 'wal 
be cost 
\Pl=311 said she as ta nora roka stow she war. laud with P2 Plan at Mady hadated ha 
awal Me Snie She ad Rany Wedet 
Web 
IttPITCAMIST•śmatniearpeoesCramaiforwenSOJIalhintitsunnamoAccno arullbjeashrlarainwStsgradarewesłACOIWI0110/10,12aarrashanw 
Po i el 
EFTA00723542

OM 
re it ea so, 
rm. 
POOOP girei,01 also show Ind b• person sale lo lea made oe bred ben ~Saar 
to Easters persebe asaltlark she h 
turn celled • Hen York corponnoneSlaird Mel tannin. tro repot slaw 
TM Usu. In the Lamm (baronet alhr limbo ere to ha %Met« Ion., in ~a 
he anew Ob. ors 
•Hey new *rued or came to IM rone: ~bar 
Said. Bek IOW, EMU«, "at Vion a PPYawn led, 'he Fasten en 
~dear 
dogs: the theme( add 
Alter Vie edelrrenl moot Egnoln 'nos unmet« ads week, Pocce CISNRetat hared the male to the FBI 'Wade nabob 
Ile Men. ant note redone% It: sod FBI sookeskonnonlJO( Og
 In Mang 
"le eNW himksnas cony at 
back Pon Eboafa Wye., eed bade In New Yak. wen he bs o tOlf,, We Now Yon 
Post Quoted Esomins pun
t New Yea soy X. Cob1/2:101(obl. es saying rks chat was Irslatal say lounge of the 
~sr 
et the poke Wet.' 
Rena has ~Wed to ~me« on Po C954 
ProstaAcea hint not preseabel a sta-rdatot ease like Epslelnk leopard My betre. aap MIke Eameetkon spokesman b 
the state attorney's oboe `Theo MM yea do with a aft that bin ede a gray area: he said. 
The state attomey's take 44 net recommarlapatratacCAMIna aurae 0.133.011t0 bib Pastern (.334 043"3, salt The Peed 
lay tale ananin0 watts NI et chows eon Wool to Wool. Man adibonace kath the Moaners ix1 of the mom, he sold. 
Wools In (Wafted at Ow yard Iwy pronto/Oa' West Palm Beech *arse eacaney Raab Tana sad 'Is a tan SY be 
posionvbe• oase to rot taw the IA noterarokty b rd MN ee lane). And not PoIng Slot the Pam Boob Ponta 
Deptelmad on* 
IPi P sonothlry tea loon wan that undesge wan: 
W arne orgy Robe Gerstman wt a amebae, b sa yen. *These pat bat time teen ~ye 
a tronntson Ir. I 
GLIT knot(' he said 
• 
011(mayi sad Eteldn's case rains the Site oe whether weary, corrialtd Ottenents Ike Conlon • Wow barb 
lofrot kmito Prenten Paean hod Bone Trumo -we ~ad ade,rdy tom ahem. Oea he ra w hewers ee sufara c< a 
~ha: mono. Eaten hood • ~Lots and:eV atiancre sue, et gort Ne end ledocal. racketed ~do& el the 
Netlona Assorteer ei Olmen: Oterree Layers. 
Men/ lawyer Roy Black -Mew recent nekorolly boom when to sursomsbly °ebbed Willem Kennel/ Small morn 
ehnlie In Ptah Beach -also war booted tent pVd. 
Said Oaken ammo( lachel* Stramon ri think Es urtotonbe the bone may Set the Peo39 3to " 4 ~ 
30330. Tea may be 
Vested eldertvely than re tols100 333
Moutmtlen: PSI7r0 (C) 
Jenny Epstein Its tenor arni 
Weed snobs trapiin, poke aso. (Mug) 
ConerrreitOit P•V•1400~~04" 
Fdttisred Jabs 
AilianTSC
IPT~199. 
Data. el Nunn% Salerno say — 
QuNDYSiatimacalt
.
CounriClub Man 
$24 Moon ~chow 
WS2.1~2.911 
CARPET Wal l/4 ROINMUOI5.... 
60YEEMPAICSPALSRCIAMT 
SOVER1151310 
BOO.C4 Ho* AM 
rea 
oile.-96s~evn.a.onievitiniánv.WAC0104.1011t12:9371amogood....n. 
on. 
EFTA00723543

AA+.. w er wen new v4 t,, tintem./.• HisilliNtiMpsee 
/*We IL+1 Av 
PalmBeachPost.com IArchives 
Job. 
Aloe 
Real Eta 
Clessiecle 
Sheints 
teak 
wee IONA 
 
kg
~c 
.w.on 
tarot 
Ilan 
Vint's. 
FA,* 
&seinen 
Ortarro-c 
Dan17.- 
Wsp 
treerinmem 
PhMtt 
'Alto 
Neg.: 
St iNZ:e5. 
fauttk I Aladidinainrati 
EXPERT: IGNORANCE OF AGE ISN'T DEFENSE IN SEX CASES 
MGM 
LARRY KELLER 
Psi,, Bann Peal Mad Was 
DATE: /soil 5. 2006 
PUBLICATION: Palm leech Pad, The (FL) 
EDITION: FINAL 
SECTION: LOCAL 
PAGE: 18 
MEMO: Ran en gigot 
Ewen If Palm Beech many renew Jeffrey Epstein 64n1 know that !pia *to pate say paw min sexual mucosa N. 
Intro:oasts/ hose wen undo tat tegel age. that None skint haw eteemptoti tin torn oh. ini Once a Hamel really net 
'von 
is het ewed delete, sad Bob Dint, *legal tubs wetness, wee was s Lake Oly pesecuta tot salt y S3 yews, 
half (Feet Urns SPeOsaling n eta elffr.et **Int cheocren. 'Them In re knetieckp element as bas the age a corgennad.' 
Mkt ski 
Nero" t1•rnssh ineettelice. Pawn Booth police salt, them net probable Clicae 10 Cline tea in. V.% Win tecthiJ sex acts 
week a ranee and lewd end wallow mcitessien. They =Mot mai Egetet tot of the ach r4 tame at Snit* Meal of 
Dentoonele Party ceparteetkee arse cartoons • oamerated troso see with Ine aw•ape yds.
n the psi vrteit. New York Attorney Gen and albennteita castelete Etat Soto tga marred tall 250.050 In ComPace 
conilbelcets he meshed Iron Eget** end Ma* Green o made, to mien Stow In he can 
bob Net returnee 110.400 to 
hire beceoSe of on Pink Beech sand* the New Yolk Da Wes tee *Parted 
Steger Man We cloven, the state soarers abbe preened the case so* county wend AO. The Pend Wisted Elton* set
l
scenes WC*, loss anima throe el teery teiegetten of peitiltden. 
The ease mbar) web-owe because cow ewe ettOcleye ogee rangy. revo,Itteke sue cNcg•n were -dm, And c Increnot 
tally 
0 pe06wating Oncl so Steno cases. cogeditty when to Wets* b encrmousty wealthy and can h* hgtt-picet1 
tooter Mayon. 
At least an d Epstein rept Joint told pelts ho knew she wee indoor when the twat decal pet nate ler freezer, end 
segue! catty. 5In was 16 neva obi at tho ante end sod Ewen asked he cannons Gni la Mph scheaL escadny to police: 
reports 
A pal rho said she me Epstein when she was 15 rid he told ter Y. she tot eeyboly wee happened se It  hone, bad things 
cat happen. Me Poke Mon Gan 
EMU**. yerandeS1 easged song vas 14 sten she says she par tern o massage Ortg It'4od writ Saul Whit. She as now 
it The 911's Wa says he don t knot/ whethe• she act Epstein kw age 
'Wry clateder as kept 0 let 
vAnr reopened toe me tang 
6 shoo casecerassrnert.' 
lit Ike ebe wry mien toted 
TA Any rudPil marteoukt tww 100 aura! IIICYgra SPA 
Wenn Sternly Jack Goldberger mainline the not Orgy cbd Epstein ins a pcannaph test atonic he 60 not tee the gide 
was etas, Pith* slabs weal Creclie. The slate 4110.ney'S ofko also ImpLed the: Their ctedbity Ines en Issue vAwi II 
deckled rag to chars Epstein dimly. 06 Weft ONO the case to Se Got goy. 
'A posccutor has to bark at, I In a much beode• bslicet: a stele esomnyt erobevnen said last week. 
Epstein heed tenet taw Prieto( Alan DefOgrall VANIP1 he became swat he was Cale• irninegallon. end Dorshomu pert 
PeSeagers Inlertratiew that some el the weed Cedes had ercko 6 Wang aeons we, reefewria on a Peedee Web see. 
•ccodrg to a Palm Masi *grin moot. 
Pronto= tysicafy comber Iwo Pinot In decking whether to charge sonnet* SIN seurelancl *Senses nett mine* 
age
, Mete Is stair% reeal one neater there Is a putt* intent In sing ea Oat Bald 
Web 
Ir-JP21067.11, 4 CinahlieVatlArOth t.s.V"erntimiluir..o0.• :131USNA COMS3.%eaut- -.Se, I 
tl 0510214171.1•24j.erSitie. re 
/op I e 
EFTA00723544

ONAt lent kr PS KS. kyr inn I WM fan o. ee f$ INS wan 
V ITC Ieco I VI In • UMW velexsish:p and DIe Coy turns 16 beta the On. he Wad be charged *Moses otto I the se. 
Pass. 
There road to no sullic beeves's-. ounsteng Use, Der* said 
But seen nee Is 
S. Ib
 BOP n pee • and sepocaSy In owes et lesotwit wen Maas • from Is • fikflic Mouth 
pitsecittem. he SOB Likewise it the eCCUllel has a track wad dies MIT Janet. 
SUE Ben it • steirrsteitanstart in prostOuting these cases. Dade as Man who espied tramp glisten ix sex oleo 
catettly Owe* heir gams In My* Owl WI mininne the that to Work he slid. 
Yams teveity we Itote • Iowa,  sober sego.. and they bey bob from penciesecat robin 
Maw and. 
tat a chid sent erase slctens he* been Vellmized by mullige peep, oar a poled el Ems. Ten the act el abuse ore:loon 
betrayIn the Valan MX toter clareges Peet ekkittarf." ExaTateek Wake Paintaaktut tan 
ere  enr3 •Ba. 
Son* et the eileged Jan* to the Etielein salt retained fa his hove maple ernes be the grosser swab's are the $203 IC 
SiK0 he type-thy paid Mir pr Veit. 'Thal acted be ei debit* pithier bin the rtriecaer; aid Bay Rasa ire restaract 
Watt aggro' denten in Palm Bosch County lot ha yews one now Is In oche* breaker In take Worth 
'The *Ion bacon= less synallictif los)" 
Reich said TM She's a Octet hhertlyhiss She's a 
' 
Mom men carped with sex sexes spirt( minces task namS. Mak art A pay expecting to eke a monster beer, wit. Ant 
the edgers" ease wait assensl them el, it lea et the diardWit heel* Done saki 
a child end in schO to Ogren, stases and both swear they* Whig ant with MA jinn aye nice DM to Wane be adds. 
Doke Seel 
'You ha* ail those things WWIVIO erns' you In • the sex abuts Cain. Prosecif.as namely try to be .e' ea-ati h Ping 
those cases because Pry turn *se reser pelting kik). MOM a no nth sting b w intencled Chid seam abate care' 
tstry_iudelasbeettorn 
Ulaitracer PHOTO (C) 
Jens/ Epstein'. The pea: ens hest returned donalons sive he Wos charged wen reciting e'en (exig) 
Copy...VW WA Pas seep+ srnix•Pro 11 
Featured 
Jobs 
0821GISRALIES. 
SCDICOSE SUER BUSY KBE HEM* 
MARC, knensdiste 
caeRSB 
CATERF10 SOPERWS01I. el 
LX5C6WS55151- 011 
LIG& ASSUSTANIT to AV end PIG. _ 
tivAg 
*VAC SEANCE TECHetiCirei.SE 11. Omens 
. 
v.... R., Rater: Jab: 
Copy* ri 2008, Tit Pala Reath Post A0 tights named. 
By wing PalmIkeeliPostecm> >tea accept tha Cc Moir >Idol reset 
please matt a, 
CPINPaglftiggile2M 
ratIcnillet 
I (Bahgett 
AtibBefer thh Trc Peg I Aria' 305±6124 
aim 11.4Y 
ParfrOrmea"AssemsnoStres90.40:•exSok•SILMWACC4141111%6XPs. aS.35.bconvessujsrwm.copepskspy....40:04: gtosnipale.wysearn. 
So- 2v) 
EFTA00723545

JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 
Date Of Photo: 08/03/2O09 
Florida Department of Law Enforcement - Sexual Offender / Predator Flyer 
Click Here to Track this Offender 
Designation: Swami Offender 
Name: JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 
Status: Supervised - FL Dept of 
Corrections 
Department of 
Corrections N: 
W35755 
Search the Dept of 
Corrections Website 
Date of Birth: 01/20/1953 
Race : White 
Sex: Male 
Hair: Grey 
Eyes: Blue 
Height: 6'00" 
Weight: 180 lbs 
EPSTEIN is registered as a Sexual Offender. 
Positive Identification cannot be established unless a 
fingerprint comparison is made. 
Aliases 
JEFFREY EDWARD EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EPSTEIN 
Scars, Marks ft Tattoos 
Not Available 
Address Information 
Address 
Address Source Information 
Map Link 
358 El Brill° Way 
Palm Beach, FL 33480.4730 
Source: Dept. of Corrections 
Received: 08/27/2009 
Show Map 
Palm Beach COUNTY 
Type of Address: Permanent 
Crime Information - Qualifying Offenses 
Adjudication 
Date 
Crime Description 
Court Case 
Number 
Jurisdktion Et 
State 
Adjudication 
06/30/2008 
procuring a Person finder age of 18 for 
0809381 
PALM BEACH. FL 
Guilty/convict 
prostitution: F.S. 796.03 (PRINCIPAL' 
Victim Information 
Gender:Female Minor:Yes 
Arei View Vehicle and Vessel
• 
• Information 
EFTA00723546

Case 9:08-cv-80119-RAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 1 of 7 
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 
CASE NO. 08-CIV-80119-MARRA/JOHNSON 
JANE DOE NO. 2, 
Plaintiff, 
vs. 
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 
Defendant. 
Related cases: 
08-80232, 0840380, 0840381, 0840994, 
0840993, 08-80811, 08-80893, 0940469, 
09-80591, 0940656, 09-80802, 09-81092 
OMNIBUS ORDER 
THIS CAUSE is before the Court on the following motions: (1) Plaintiff' Jane Doe's 
Motion for Protective Order Barring Second Deposition and for Sanctions (D. E. #378); and, 
(2) Plaintiff Jane Doe No. 4's Motion for Protective Order Re Second Day of Deposition 
(D.E. #392). For the following reasons said Motions are granted in part and denied in part 
in accordance with the terms herein. 
In this case, which has been consolidated for purposes of discovery, Plaintiffs are 
former under-age girls who allege they were sexually assaulted by Defendant, Jeffrey 
Epstein ("Epstein"), at his Palm Beach mansion home. The scheme is alleged to have 
taken place over the course of several years in or around 2004-2005, when the girls in 
question were approximately 16 years of age. As part of this scheme, Epstein, with the 
I 
EXHIBIT. 
EFTA00723547

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 2 of 7 
help of his assistant 
allegedly lured economically disadvantaged minor girls 
to his homes in Palm beach, New York and St. Thomas, with the promise of money in 
exchange for a massage. Epstein purportedly transformed the massage into a sexual 
assault. The three-count Complaint alleges sexual assault and battery (Count I), 
intentional infliction of 
Count II), and, coercion and enticement to sexual 
activity in violation of 18 U.S.C. §2422 (Count III). 
The instant Motions are nearly Identical and seek, as to each respective Plaintiff, 
Jane Doe in the case of D.E. #378 and Jane Doe 4 in the case of D.E. #392, 
protection/limitation from having to appear at a second deposition. Jane Doe was deposed 
on September 20, 2009 for a total of anywhere between just under 7 hours to 8 hours. 
Jane Doe 4 was deposed on October 27, 2009, and the parties are in agreement that 
taking into account breaks, the deposition lasted 5 hours and 35 minutes. Plaintiffs contend 
that under Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(d)(1), S.D. Fla. L.R. 26.1(K), and the Court's Consolidation 
Order (D.E. #98), all of which limit a deposition of an individual to a single day of seven 
hours unless leave of Court is granted, it is Defendant's burden to demonstrate why more 
than seven hours of deposition time is necessary for a particular Plaintiff. According to 
Plaintiff, Epstein has failed to sustain his burden in this regard and, as such, he should not 
be able to re-depose Jane Doe at all2, and should only be able to re-depose Jane Doe 4 
' In her Motion, Jane Doe represents that she was deposed for 8 hours. For his part, 
Defendant Epstein contends in his Response in Opposition that taking into account 
lunch and other breaks, the actual figure is 6 hours and 50 minutes, which figure he 
contends was confirmed with the court reporter. The Court finds that whether Jane Doe 
was deposed for just under 7 hours as Epstein contends, or for 8 hours as Jane Doe 
alleges, is under the circumstances herein presented, of no consequence. 
This is based on Plaintiffs' representation that Jane Doe's deposition lasted 8 hours. 
2 
EFTA00723548

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 3 of 7 
for an additional 1 hour and 25 minutes, providing Epstein with an aggregate of 7 hours 
deposition time of Jane Doe 4. 
Epstein contends the Court's May 14, 2009 Consolidation Order, which provides 
that "Local Rule 26.1K (limiting deposition time to one day of seven hours) is waived so as 
to allow each party an adequate opportunity to develop fully the record as it may relate to 
that party," effectively waives L.R. 26.1K's limitation on the length of a deposition, thereby 
relieving Epstein from the seven hour deposition limit. The Court disagrees with Epstein's 
Interpretation of the District Court's Order and finds that Fed.R.Civ.P. 30(d)(1) and 
S.D.Fla.L.R. 26.1(K) which, absent agreement or court order, presumptively limits 
depositions to 7 hours, applies in this case. That said, the undersigned finds that Epstein 
has provided sufficient and reasonable grounds in his Response Memorandum to sustain 
his burden under the Rules of showing additional time to depose Jane Doe and Jane Doe 
4 Is needed to fully and fairly prepare his defense. 
Plaintiffs are seeking millions of dollars in personal Injury damages for, among other 
things, physical injury, pain and suffering, emotional distress, psychological trauma, mental 
anguish, humiliation, embarrassment, loss of self-esteem, loss of dignity, and invasion of 
privacy. Epstein's counsel represents he will need an additional 2'% to 3 hours to depose 
Jane Doe, so that he can cover such topics as background information not disclosed in 
answers to interrogatories, family background information, details regarding Jane Doe's 
visits to Epstein's home, Jane Doe's knowledge of other witnesses, school records and 
medical records, and finally, details regarding her past sexual history, an opportunity he 
did not have when he began her deposition as the Court had not yet ruled on Epstein's 
Motion to Compel (D.E. #s 67 & 68), which sought information related to Plaintiffs past 
3 
EFTA00723549

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 4 of 7 
sexual history. 
As for Jane Doe 4, Epstein's counsel represents he will need approximately an 
additional 4 hours to complete her deposition, owing to her "complicated and eventful past 
history" including alleged drug use, repeated instances of 
and arrests. Def's Resp., p. 2. Also, as with Jane Doe, Epstein's 
counsel claims he needs additional time to depose Jane Doe 4 on details regarding her 
past sexual history, an opportunity he did not have when he began her deposition as the 
Court had not yet ruled on Epstein's Motion to Compel (D.E. #s 67 & 68), which sought 
information related to Plaintiff's past sexual history. All agree that there were instances 
at Jane Doe 4's initial deposition where she was instructed by her counsel not to answer 
questions "relatied) to sexual partners' names or sexual positions." Jane Doe 4 Deposition 
Excerpt, attached as Ex. "B" to Defs Resp., at 5. With these subjects fairly open to inquiry, 
it is only reasonable that Epstein's counsel will require additional time to depose Jane Doe 
and Jane Doe 4 on these areas. 
The Court agrees with Epstein that all of the foregoing issues are directly relevant 
to Plaintiffs' damage claims and credibility, and to deny him additional time in which to 
depose these Plaintiffs would be unreasonable under the circumstances and result in 
prejudice to Epstein by denying him the opportunity to obtain discovery that is central to 
his defense. See Osborne v. Columbia Helicopters, Inc., 2009 WL 2215076 (S.D. W.Va. 
2009)(granting the defendant an additional one day of 7 hours to depose the plaintiff, 
reasoning that because the plaintiff provided incomplete written discovery responses, the 
defendant "did not have full opportunity to examine Mr. Osborne respecting all of the 
information which might properly be considered in his discovery deposition."). 
4 
EFTA00723550

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 5 of 7 
Nonetheless, with the Court now having the benefit of the 446 page, three-volume 
deposition transcript, a copy of which is attached to Plaintiffs' Appeal of Magistrate Judge 
Decision (D.E. #430), the Court finds the 4 additional hours requested by Defendant to 
depose Jane Doe 4 unreasonable under the circumstances. A review of the deposition 
transcript reveals numerous instances of Jane Doe 4 being subjected to repetitive 
questioning about exceedingly sensitive issues such as the emotional pain caused by 
the sexual positions she has engaged in, and Epstein's treatment 
of her. To re-phrase Plaintiffs' counsel's words', while it may be appropriate to ask a 
plaintiff in a personal injury case a question about whether 
caused her 
when the essentially identical question is re-phrased and asked over 
and over again, the questioning becomes badgering and harassing. 
Counsel for 
Defendant must be mindful that the depositions of the Plaintiffs in these cases covers the 
most intimate and private details of their lives and if not handled correctly may serve to 
needlessly revictimize, embarrass and humiliate them. 
In order to avoid this result, in all future depositions of the Plaintiffs in these cases, 
including the re-depositions of Jane Doe and Jane Doe 4, Defendant's counsel is ordered 
to refrain from repetitive questioning. This does not mean that Defense counsel may not 
follow-up on questions asked or ask similar questions of a related nature, but counsel is 
expected to conduct himself in a responsible and professional manner befitting members 
of the Bar and balance the need for the information sought against the psychological 
trauma that could result from repetitive, humiliating questions regarding the sensitive 
' See Plaintiffs' Appeal of Magistrate's Order (D.E. #430), p.6-7. 
5 
EFTA00723551

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 6 of 7 
issues at play in this case. 
As for the time permitted defense counsel to re-depose these Plaintiffs, the Court 
finds that any remaining questions regarding Jane Doe 4 or Jane Doe 4's sexual history 
can fairly and reasonably be covered in 2 hours, rather than the 4 hours requested, and 
that any remaining questions regarding Jane Doe or Jane Doe's sexual history can fairly 
and reasonably be covered in the requested 3 hours. The Court's allowance of this 
additional time should not be construed by defense counsel as authority to take the 
depositions of these Plaintiffs for any longer time than is necessary, and in no event will 
the Court tolerate questioning of an abusive nature. In accordance with the above and 
foregoing, it is hereby 
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Plaintiff Jane Doe's Motion for Protective Order 
Barring Second Deposition and for Sanctions (D.E. #378); and Plaintiff Jane Doe No. 4's 
Motion for Protective Order Re Second Day of Deposition (D.E. #392) are GRANTED IN 
PART AND DENIED IN PART in accordance with the terms of this Order. Epstein's 
counsel is hereby given leave to re-depose Jane Doe for up to 3 additional hours and 
hereby given leave to re-depose Jane Doe 4 for up to 2 additional hours. Counsel for the 
parties are ordered to immediately confer and come to mutual agreement on a date and 
time in which these depositions can be continued sometime within two (2) weeks from the 
date hereof, unless otherwise agreed to by the parties. Plaintiffs' request for sanctions is 
denied. 
DONE AND ORDERED this December 3, 2009, in Chambers, at West Palm Beach, 
Florida. 
6 
EFTA00723552

Case 9:08-cv-80119-KAM Document 433 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/03/2009 Page 7 of 7 
4 176.0,t_-,,
LINNEA R. JO 
ON 
UNITED STA 
S MAGISTRATE JUDGE 
CC: 
The Honorable Kenneth A. Marra 
All Counsel of Record 
7 
EFTA00723553

Jeffrey Epstein 
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 
(Redirected from Jeffrey epstein) 
Jeffrey Epstein (born January 20, 1953 in Coney Island, New York) is an American financier, billionaire and 
philanthropist. 
Epstein was raised in Coney Island and attended Lafayette High School in Brooklyn, New York. He attended 
classes at Cooper Union from 1969 to 1971 and then at the Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, leaving 
without a degree. From 1973 to 1975 he taught calculus and physics at the Dalton School. He then became a 
trader at Bear Stearns. In 1982 he founded his own financial management firm, J. Epstein and Co. and later 
called Financial Trust Co., located on his private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. He reportedly only takes 
billionaire clients; one client was his mentor and friend Les Wexnerll) who recently hired Dennis Hersch to 
replace Epstein t21 
Since all but one of his clients are anonymous, it has been speculated that Epstein's lavish lifestyle is primarily 
financed by Wexner.lil 
Epstein has befriended high profile scientists such as Leonard Susskind, Richard Axel, Gerald Edelman, Murray 
Gell-Mann, Ben Goertzel, and Marvin Minsky, and politicians including George J. Mitchell and Bill Clinton. In 
September 2002 he flew Bill Clinton, Kevin Spacey and Chris 'Ricker to Africa in his private Boeing 727, to 
promote the ex-president's anti-AIDS efforts.l11
Epstein is a friend and supporter of theoretical biologist Martin Nowak. He funded Nowak's research at the 
institute for Advanced Study in Princetonlil and in 2003 pledged S30 million to Harvard University to fund the 
.iewly created Program for Evolutionary Dynamics there which Nowak directs.13H 
He is a former board member of Rockefeller University, a member of the New York Academy of Sciences, the 
Trilateral Commission, and the Council on Foreign Relations, and a visiting fellow at Harvard University. He 
has also funded microbiology experiments in Bangladesh, particle physics in South Africa and M-theory in 
India and was a founding member of the Scholar Rescue Fund. Epstein is a former trustee of the International 
Institute for Education, the parent organization of the Fulbright Program. He has held conferences on artificial 
intelligence, cosmology and the origin of life with prominent scientists. 
In addition to his private island in the Virgin Islands (Little St. James Island), Epstein owns a 50,000-square-
foot (4,600 m2) townhouse in Manhattan that was formerly owned by Les Wexner, a villa in Palm Beach, 
Florida and a fortress on a ranch in Santa Fe, New Mexico.!;! 
He is often accompanied on his trips and at his mansions by his close friend Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of the 
late British publisher Robert Maxwell° He is also often seen surrounded by young women, some of which are 
employed as his personal assistants.!'! In September 2007 one woman described how she had been hired by 
Ghislaine Maxwell as a masseuse and assistant to Epstein and had engaged in sexual acts.i° 
Police investigation 
In March 2005, a woman contacted Palm Beach police, concerned that her 14-year-old step daughter had been 
tolested by a wealthy man. The daughter told police that she had been paid $300 for giving a massage to 
Epstein in his mansion. She had told him that she was 18 years old .l° He had ordered her to take off her clothes; 
she had undressed but had left on her underwear. During the massage he had masturbated him 
applied a vibrator to her crotch!~1 
EFTA00723554

Police started an 11-month undercover investigation of Epstein, followed by a search of his home. Subsequently 
they alleged that Epstein had paid several underage girls to perfonn sexual acts on him. Interviews with five 
alleged victims and 17 witnesses under oath, phone messages, a high school transcript and other items they 
found in Mr. Epstein's trash and home allegedly show that he knew how young the girls were.ls) A search of 
Epstein's home found numerous photos of nude young girls throughout the house, some of whom had been 
iterviewed earlier by the police.n He had set up a system of young women recruiting other women for his 
massage services, paying $200 for each referrals) Two housekeepers stated to the police that Epstein would 
receive two to three massages per day whenever he stayed in Palm Beach.171 In May 2006, Palm Beach police 
filed a probable cause affidavit saying that Epstein should be charged with four counts of unlawful sex with 
minors and one molestation coup irl 
iew, one of the girls related that she repeatedly had 
lesbian sex with Epstein's friend 
in his presence; she stated he "had purchased her from her 
family in Yugoslavia. Epstein bragged he brought her into the United States to be his Yugoslavian sex slave."t91
His team of lawyers included Gerald B. Lefcourt, Alan Dershowitz and later also Kenneth Starr?) They stated 
that Epstein never knew of the under-age status of his masseuses, which was confirmed by subjecting him to a 
lie detector test.") They also questioned the credibility of the teenage accusers, based in part on their MySpace 
postings and information obtained by private investigators?? t1 
Instead of following the recommendation of the police, the prosecutors considered the evidence weak") and 
presented it to a grand jury, an uncommon procedure in non-capital cases. The grand jury returned only a single 
charge of felony solicitation of prostitution,I123 to wm 
• • ch Epstein pleaded not guilty in August 2006.1" ) The Palm 
Beach police chief, angered about this minor charge and suspecting preferential treatment of the wealthy, 
complained to the state attorney and then turned the case over to the FB1.151
In December 2007, it was reported that Epstein was involved in plea negotiations and was expected to plead 
guilty to a charge of soliciting prostitution and spend about 18 months in jail?) A guilty plea was finally 
wonted on lune 30, 2008. 
After the accusations became public, several parties returned donations they had received from Epstein, 
including Eliot L. Spitzer, Mark A. Green, Bill Richardson,141and the Palm Beach police department's) Harvard 
announced that it would not return any money?)
Civil lawsuits alleging child molestation, assault 
In a related case, Epstein was sued in October 2007 by Maximilia Cordero, a male-to-female transgender 
model, who claims Epstein forced her into a sexual relationship at the age of 16.1131
On February 6, 2008, an anonymous Virginia woman filed a $50 million civil lawsuitt141 in federal court against 
Epstein, alleging that when she was a 16-year-old minor in 2004-2005, she was "recruited to give Epstein a 
massage." After being brought to his Palm Beach mansion, she claims that he exposed himself and sexually 
assaulted her, and paid her $200 immediately afterward.112) A similar $50 million suit was filed by a different 
woman in March 2008 who was represented by the same lawyer -Vs)
References 
. A 
it 
c Landon Thomas Jr. (2002-10-28). "Jeffrey Epstein: international Money Man of Mystery 
(http://nymag.com/nytnetroinews/peoplein_79120 ". New York http://nymag.cominymetto/news/people/n_7912/. 
2. A "IPMorgan's Herscb succeeds colorful money manager (http://blogs.reuters.com/reuters-
dealzone/2008/02/11/jpmorgans-hersch-succeeds-colorful-money-manager0 ". Reuters. Thomson Reuters. 2008-02-
11. http://blogsseuters.conteuters-dealzone/2008/02/11/jpmorgans-hersch-succeeds-colorful-money-managert 
3. A Financier pledges $30 million to support Harvard researcher, The Associated Press, 7 February 2003 
4. A 6 c "Harvard to Keep Epstein Gift (http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx7refn514187) ". The Harvard Crimson 
(Harvard University). 2006-09-13.. http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref-.514187. Retrieved 2007-09-13. 
EFTA00723555

5. Agree'
 if
 "The Fantasist (http://nymag.cotn/news/features/418260 ". New York 2007-12-10. 
http://nymag.com/newsleatures/41826/. 
6. A a "Prince Andrew's friend, Ghislaine Maxwell, some underage girls and a very disturbing story 
(http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/pages/live/femail/article.html?in_article_id•4834018dn_page_id=1879) ", The Mail 
On Sunday, 23 September 2007 
7. AS
I
 e Palm Beach police probable cause affidavit against Jeffrey Epstein 
(hup://www.thesmoldnggun.com/archive/0726062epstein 1 limn) , The Smoking Gun 
8. A 
e "Jeffrey Epstein craved big homes, elite friends - and, investigators say, underage girls 
(http://www.palrobeachpost.com/localnews/content/localnews/epaper/2006/08/14hrilaFYSTEIN 0814.html) 'I. 
Palm Beach Post 2006-08-14. 
hup://www.palmbeachpost.comllocalnews/conteat/local news/epaper/D06/08/141m1a_EPSTEIN 0814.html. 
9. A 'Exclusive: Jeffrey Epstein's Sex Slave (http://gawkercomlnews/crime/exclusive-jeffrey-epsteins-sex-slave-
190625.php) ". Gawker.com. Gawker Media. 2006-07-28. http://pwker.com/newskrime/exclusive-jeffrey-epsteins-
sex-slave-190625.php. Retrieved 2008-02-24. 
10. A'  6 "COPS' FLOPS LETTING MOGUL GET OFF EASY 
(hur//www.nypostcom/seven/11122007/news/nationathews/cops_flops_letting_mogul_get_off easy_303421.htm) 
". New York Post. 2007-11-12. 
http://www.nypostcom/seven/11122007/news/nationalnews/cops_flops_letting_mogul_get_off easy_303421.htm. 
11. A 
"Questions of Preferential Treatment Are Raised in Florida Sex Case 
(btp://vAvw.nytiniescom/2006/09/03/us/03epstein.html) ". The New York Times. 2006-09-03. 
hup://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/03/us/03epstein.html. 
12. A'  6 Keller, Larry (2008-02-06). "Second teen-sex suit seeks $50 million from Jeffrey Epstein 
(hup://www.palmbeachpost.com/localnews/content/local news/epaper/2008/02/06/0206EPSTEN.hunfi ". Palm 
Beach Post http://www.palmbeachpostcom/localnews/content/local_news/epaper/2008/02/06/0206F-PSTEIN.html. 
13. A "GENDER-BEND SHOCKER 
(htrp://www.nypost.com/seven/10232007/newsfregionalnewrigender_bend_shocker.htm) ". New York Post. 2007-10-
23. http://www.nypost.corn/seven/10232007/news/regionalnews/gender_bend_shockerltm. 
14. A 'Billionaire Faces $50M Sexual Assault Lawsuit 
(littp://news.findlaw.com/hdocs/docs/pi/doeepstein20608cmp.html) ". FindLaw. 2008.02-06. 
http://news.fincUaw.coroThdocs/docs/pi/doeepstein20608cmp.htinl. 
15. A Keller, Lany (2008-03-05). "Third alleged victim files sex suit against Jeffrey Epstein 
(http://www.palmbeachpost.com/localnewskontent/local news/epaper/2008/03/05/0305epstein.html) ". Palm Beach 
Post. hup://www.palmbeachpost.comllocalnewskontent/local_news/epaper/2008/03/05/0305epstein.html. 
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wildileffrey_Epstein" 
Categories: 1953 births I Living people I American businesspeople I American philanthropists I American 
billionaires I American Jews I Harvard University people I People from Brooklyn I The Cooper Union alumni I 
American sex offenders 
e This page was last modified on 1 January 2010 at 07:50. 
■ Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may 
apply. See Terms of Use for details. 
Wilcipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wildmedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. 
▪ Contact us 
EFTA00723556

Web injeggi Videos Mans News Shopping Gmail more 
[email protected] I Web History I Settings v I Sion ou, 
Gocsie  :Jeffrey epstein" 
Search 1 My... 
Search 
Web 
Show options,. 
Results 1 - 10 of about 38,600 for "Jeffrey epstein". (031 seconds) 
Jeffrey Epstein - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 
Jeffrey Epstein (born January 20, 1953 in Coney Island, New York) is an American financier, 
billionaire and philanthropist and convicted chid sex offender.... 
en.wikipedia.orghviki/Jeffrey_Epstein - Cached - Similar -
Jeffrey Epstein's "Sweetheart" Plea Deal, Embarrassing Deposition ... 
Sep 17, 2009 ... UPDATE 9/18: (Scroll down for video of Epstein's embarrassing deposition.) 
Epstein's secret plea deal on his original criminal teenage ... 
VAvw.huffingtonpost.com/.../egg-shaped-penis-jeffrey_n_290464.html - Cached -
Jeffrey Epstein: International Moneyman of Mystery 
He's pals with a passel of Nobel Prize—winning scientists, CEOs like Leslie Wexner of the 
Limited, socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, even Donald Trump. 
nyrnag.com/nymetro/news/peopleM_7912/- Cached - Similar -
Video: Lawyer Asks Jeffrey Epstein If His Wang Is Indeed 'Eoq 
Sep 17, 2009 ... Video: Lawyer Asks Jeffrey Epstein If His Wang is Indeed 'Egg-Shaped' ... 
this video of accused sex offender Jeffrey Epstein being asked, ... 
nymag.com/daily/intel/2009/..Jvideo_lawyer_asks_epstein_if h.Mml - Cached - 
Image results for leffrev epstein" - Report imams 
Jeffrey Epstein - West Palm Beach & Treasure Coast area breaking ... 
Feb 17, 2009 ... Judge: Palm Beach sex offender Jeffrey Epstein agreement to remain 
sealed ... Billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein has been sentenced to 18 ... 
www.palmbeachpostcom/localnews/..J0217epstein.html - Cached - Similar -
Jeffrey Epstein Kept Company in Jail By His Alleged Lesbian Sex ... 
Jul 22, 2009 ... Billionaire convicted sex offender Jeffery Epstein Is now a free man. He did his 
12 months for hiring underage prostitutes, and left Jail... 
gawker.com/. ./jeffrey-epsteln-kept-company-in-jail-by-his-alleged-lesbian-sex-slave - 
Jeffrey Epstein To Roam Free at First Liqht - leffrey epstein - Gawker 
Jul 21, 2009 ... Billionaire teen-girl-massage aficionado Jeffrey Epstein is won to be a free 
man! As dawn breaks on Wednesday, the gates of the Palm Beach ... 
gawker.com/5319678/Jeffrey-epstein-to-roam-free-at-first-light -
Show more results from clawker,com 
EXCLUSIVE: Jeffrey Epstein To Be Released From Prison Early ... 
Jun 19, 2009 ... Jeffrey Epstein, the Florida money manager who once roamed in the same 
social circle as Bill Clinton, Prince Andrew and other high profile ... 
www.radaronline.com/.../exclusive-Jeffrey-epstein-be-released-prison-eady -
Cached - Similar - 
Citvfile: Jeffrey Epstein Goes Free, Reunites With His 'Sex Slave' 
EFTA00723557

Jul 22, 2009 ... Guess who's been released from prison? That would be Jeffrey Epstein. the 
secretive money manager who pleaded guilty in 2007 to soliciting ... 
cityfile.com/dailyfile/6615 - Cached - 
Is Jeff Epstein Also Running A Ponzi Scheme? 
Jul 22, 2009 ... Jeffrey epstein Palm Beach billionaire Jeffrey Epstein left the Palm Beach 
County ... Jaded Billionaire Jeffrey Epstein Eating Moon Pies, -. 
www.businessinsider.cordis-convicted-sex-offender-jeff-epstein-running-a-ponzi-scheme-2009 
-7-Cached-
Searches related to: "Jeffrey epstein" 
jeffrey epstein palm 
jeffrey epstein ahislaine 
Jeffrey epstein bear 
j ffrev epstein 
beach 
maxwell 
stearns 
Jeffrey epstein miami 
I 2 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 js 
Next 
Personalized based on your web history. More details 
Add a result - See all my SearchWiki notes - See all notes forihis SearchWiki - Learn more 
("jeffrey epstein" 
Search I 
Search within results - Lanaume Tools - Search Help - Dissatisfied? Help us improve - Try Goode Experimental 
Gooale Home - Advertising Programs - Business Solutions - Privacy -About Goodie 
EFTA00723558

DIWO N• MT D1I CHM ARM, - A rawer Ne. York Pea 
ORM 11:XAM 
BILLIONAIRE'S DEFENSE ARMY 
New York Post • New York. N.Y. 
Date: 
Aug 9,7006 
Sian Page: 
011 
Section: 
Page Six 
Ted Word Camp 117 
Document Text 
BLLIONNRE Jeffrey Epstein has hind a platoon of 
p4-bull lawyers and publicists b rebut occusations 
that he regularly enjoyed nude massages and sex 
vitt underage gins. An ii -month pcotse by Florida 
prosecutors resulted In just one charge against 
Epstein - that he &arched happyendings' tom adult 
masseuses al his Palm Beach estate. Now the 
fanner partner of kbrt Zuckerman in Radar magazine 
Is repped by* Dream Team a tamers -Nan 
Derstweritz.Roylilackelaa Goldberger and Gerald 
Lelcoun- plus p.r. gurus Howard Rubenstein and Dan 
teems. Goldberger is discredit/1g some of Epstain's 
accusers as untrustworby drug-abusers end loaf 
cops as childish' He toid the Palm Beach Post. 
'These women ore liars. W010 eitteblished that' 
Reproduced Mal ponnition of the cogyhrt owls. FOAM 
Rhpe0Ou0011 Or chtbeollon tspeOhitstog felhoul peinliaion. 
Now to make electricity 
Freak of nature has electric CO's Executives 
shakin' in they boots 
%wow Powc,411,,ent.com 
tilyfljs 
Search multiple engines el once for newspaper 
archives 
wont wobainklegtom 
dultifildsaftstress 
Wnet concerns you the most? Share your opinion 
el Harry Reid. 
HsayRneo co& 
Abstract (Document Summery) 
BILLIONAIRE Jeffrey Epstein has hired a platoon of 04ml' lawyers ens pubiasts so rebut accus °lions fhal he 
regillorlyfirljOygg nude massages and &emir, endorsor, tallS. 
RerOduCad Mph perinpoon of the oopynghi pint. Funny reproducinon a etaisteeen is aerosolise what oorrnfafor. 
rinfinarthMeltwal anhirTa-tisilM:7070:.rentP0d1=10937076.entestteSszn.tesfuer•OnikacnIWONATIE trS•DEP CHM •Altialah I 
Pet Pt 
EFTA00723559

Oreer anst4. or Po+ tv." oaro. W I. tas ~om 4 eo Ins Mol mam 
SIM »MIN 
PalmBeadiPosicom f,lrchivces 
Joh: 
~os 
Reel Slab 
aseest 
Shopps2 
Ik .0 
riatIritis 
åB1 
Web 
Wrat 
'ban 
V
IVIO: 
ketel 
IkehH4f 
t 
9,,n1pon 
LIPPO 
eltrairtte4 
;holes 
e20,7 
SeMcn Optiietz 
afat 
jei I Wart a New Saareh 
MASSAGING THE SYSTEM 
OME: Atomist 16 2036 
PUISLICAITON: Palm Noch Poel, Te (n) 
EIETION: MAL 
SECTIOM appel 
PAGE, 700. 
Pern Merren Wee 081 OM 111DOW MOStroxial shows trol Wyeatold ~Me 
Win ~ani Jordn Epsten Ønen 
trimt" tex att nith «d leed eed leSOMO.3 moldhase on ka trallellehfa perse *Money Jack frOlObetfle dann 
Ma RØ, mee> Epston, had no klm Mg Pre enmened gek he Meed IV ~In 
Ø 
eenos 
Th• "
In mat" ca" Sta" tonemela 0500 Ca° ~ 
M a >fleer:te Mom lo telex Inter" Stiet Arktney Sry 
/Mischee belt the gutee to ttorder WIM* the 8)13km Wad In bic of a tuantlisi. vesSetnnoded aleoed ~eg« 
and minst 
gay yeeet3 in SID re• MOS neme Olga CSM, It Matte toot Me "aug stop et raten-no the aha to • grand 'dry, 
wtch last mach ~led Jekno Epstan en as labo" wint of solleation o'seosUbton, TW neen ion tame abn Manore 4. 
Prtdesso- Men Derehorrki Met apr peso:~ 
to meldenip thte,~fity d the 14 to Wyear4d pets eh* c:hard Met Me 
hpsteln hee pad lin 5200 b WO to orde* fl  enetomme Net In he hetediverni, i Wheel home en the Penstoeslat 
Wittnef. 
the dt. Mr. DeaMmer tok p~dons 
meen en myripece.00n ebni meekon min:Lena ard Otakino 
time me 
Wit tutet ~bilt2 ~k
in\ *WI Me" SMY Insta? iet. Gateitioit. 106 ihe Poet . Mc raten eesoviey Westen 
aratody lino eense l0 Ms house ba oor the media. N» he welke Pot. i dont Wow? MO memetntet toot ihM* tita vcoel 
Peten tazdoetortrO0ene• Ihm rohrles Je•rts frak** Panne Pokt searelted his none ond pntove end tand paap 
meastroee etat Wie paar ecto schedules and Inas • NO OØ threo60- 5•05selin? Met ia Entten N Cl Mto 13,01 the 
tb wca fremgen. 
Toe sta eiterrtala c&t bon responded to cair..nan San Palm Bosch pchee and ethers by helse) Me heler standerd 
posesho fox br walotion pol bvne~errent «Ion Oe br anna. Mattes case. tm Mede rattoney botoa to as a). 
OSB lun mighlIcott si bolk .regroy Epon ord fe (Okt. ent( O•nt keen a bath Otbea. 
toorn 19 IM 4n. tosa b ImP•ined es proctadee, acholueion cl a m'nef is • olme. Fine die koehel and 10~ 
Bruno ~
0
Was ohrege0 WO Mar MMO«. ~galmt 
ny Co ~0 
~0 Cie klaren - myspx..teell • th Moeit e th-yest-old, 
Pote. caf •••••Y EPMern utad t Wye8r4d 1.17nan wto had a *set:0es.~ ~WI: bravo* yang gna. Isa naons nat 
situdy. t ~0 
have been oo:d to *al e hts »SI Sri ~grol way na. 
eas)qNeystee Platepus Nowswink ae 
JUVI 
L met:giri 
TOP STOMS 
Wals goecwojeca eter 
vitae oaleapected to delete; 
~is 
VOST taaktlto tutaabg saCdtoe Va& 
Tr~3 e IBM lany 
locate•Oteareen en Os 
tweeens are Oeme to WI nnke br tomt 
Int ~let ettsf& ~ingemene:toe zwart 
Per.OISCaQ.Ontatrentunartor.~4:00/«.5,13$3.111e4171.0aMlan...wen•leotedne.s.~dss.k..~..08..seawnems,mmsispw.,,,,,.... 
sns d , 
EFTA00723560

OM dk•enr, V In, Mar, we, nil St bitelautiftdatIaliternitrnmenet 
Naas II,K.e 
PairnBeachPost.com i Archives 
bsett<;tt t: 
(the 
nett Ihtsdlyiek&troatt. 
•Stee.-;t‘stte.V.St'.,t,Skh,"---. 
•ir-SWO;fraiOrtnt 
SW 
Web 
Efet ht. acme: 
rate« 
Jots 
Adm. 
RealfskS 
estatteada, 
Shwpkva 
Hale 
mane 
tlt •• 
sienna' 
Spout 
~Iron 
Crlsorilet 
Orb: 
v:ew, 
Scrum: ordom 
Stgam I Startslintaamb 
HE WAS OVER 50. AND THEY WERE GIRLS 
BYLINE Erie Game 
DATE: Meet 1, 2006 
PUBLICATION: Pam Beam Post, Ike (FL) 
EDIDON: MAL 
SECTION OPIWY4 
PAGE: 20A 
V ew ~rim slab Pam Bach Nita soy a pentbse tom resident :need to Ns home mid pod kr am eats ttra In tad, 
aria 
the sotablion page warns:~ Epstein men teel !ONO Whale& Ott. sdistIng to pacts macs they werenl 
Hs was trend And they view aids 
44 15 
16 
17-yeakaa girls. 
1St Shedd tea te so/wetted - tM dItletenco Stade artstetnon end ped,:o~ 
Ennis Nebo Vat 1k. Ewan, Wm vas ~pi 
tem month bya yard Myatt one bray cam d ethetolkn cf probblIon 
SS not ban cadged, b NW, actet, hake glartastilY ~SS Ishii ~Ai 
sett eats viii • reha end lewd ere, eischkus 
mdestatnn 
CoWctler, d  tames aminst m ram ,.ala mean steeper penalties than Ow mailmen bayed Person ken IN. E-IWW. Wes 
~06 
G. the Dade Win ce Merry sokraticit P Sus "add kly tirye mower understand to weak ete prey on pts. 
Prosecubs etc rOt pnia) ctiVaste Karen Its Emhart reacted the ape et Me Scans lassos° Mk 'muffled • by sold eta 
ss tide net os ~ma OA as sterntraina. triliusborthy. MusD prIldpents. 'Me peaurnakn le ~to 
Mt. Epsttin.e 53-yiewiti lanittal WWII manager dank Wed Hatted ta  ~set 
Agn DendatrwM and debase looney 
Jack addbertmr. ha Coded knookg has eV lb Ørk -re But poles inkreests arth keedepol Nelms md 17 varecess 
tsar park at welt as gho6e seinfeal.•MM Wool tiareal( end Obi Aetna Pot police burd kern one? Mr. Ebtekk 
oath end 7,234w~ 
was
 hems prole Nara that ho knew the pans bra kedged. 
One gel couldn't them ket WWI Mr. Epstein sacked beast she he soccer. Malte time, Mr. Epstein bed to vat tor Ns 
better' mason Dame Pe pit Ss toad real ~In de« 
Wiry atit Su, Mossy Sew Nilarv tektite% otelde whether ha Wow ire deepen - ladero e 16.yoeretd see ads to 
Mr Eggers ham to "sod' el Odambre 2004 Met bone asked Mtatter who noble to make shanty b Cietalmes Des? 
Pa:~ 
pea lane W0;0 to the dead. Ati Cershowitz padded abed the rift In on apesete. end ta snar their 
characur. W. Dershosts ponied de lo poboAcia lb: some a the (enryen hod hake on mye pace ØØ 
~Lyn 
ard eldtatl 
Ards» ro charges «bass ~yen% tow been Ides ote pima det keel one lathe teenage bairns ~trite 
to edda 
&tieing Slaved end labbated bl him men. Poke debunked Mot their wind« ems fesiateted lo Na NW, ~gates. 
W. Odcbsr eased knotting mytheg axe k. 
Poked We ride fri thee am" Mot it. ate ettommon eke oherd W. Epstein • den sat tat void 'WC rWeed Sn. an 
taatettOttlae ese 
lam darnels& te ate SW/ sala ro aaana Neat sa tak 
Inked W. Widen spokesman, saw Etboneten. why the we vas ~sod to • rend hey uredd or Mr. Epstein herd 
and 
end tackle o Vtd belie a jay. Are ~Ialt the ticket' creSettry be a teed to deternere ~Cher • abaft teen 
errand. hol 
DorkTI Wet el. et Lor. Canker,  tote tee Pda Beash Pat d Mr. Eaten, *EleY new 
deeded gib ere to tie hide') 
reFAøneatntØYNM1suq,.Nl.r.'¢nasY.m[O.3L>IDW- 
ta.~ 
st.y.ciry 
cow ipunnen".~..-, 
10” 
EFTA00723561